Seth Meyers came out with a new stand-up special on Netflix, Lobby Baby, which released earlier this month. All in all, this special was generally pretty average. This is the first I’m seeing of Seth Meyers’ actual stand up and it wasn’t spectacular, but I wouldn’t call it disappointing either. Let’s get into it.
The first issue that I take with this special is that he has no real comedic voice. His style heavily resembles that of Mike Birbiglia and at times, John Mulaney, and rarely sounds like something the audience has never heard before. Other comedians in their first go at Netflix specials (See: Daniel Sloss, Aparna Nancherla, James Acaster, Beth Stelling) have distinct comedic voices that an audience can really connect with and enjoy. Having a well-defined voice adds to the uniqueness of your perspective in comedy. It makes it seem like you have something original to say. This is an issue that I also had with Michael Che’s first Netflix special, Michael Che Matters, in that it never sounded like either of these people had a reason to be doing comedy. They can tell jokes, but they could be anybody’s jokes. Nothing is separating them from any other comedian, and I would’ve rather them have their own comedic voices.
With that being said, I think that his funniest jokes were the ones where he wasn’t imitating anyone else. They were smart and thought-out and didn’t sound like they had been perfected by a writing staff. I recognized a few points where an older audience that knew him only from SNL would laugh, but surprisingly, none of it felt like Late Night, which was a big plus.
He circled back to jokes twice, and it closed the show nicely, but the ending, in my opinion, was too close to the first mention of that callback material. This happens a lot, and it’s where the comedian doesn’t let the original joke sit with the audience long enough for it to be funny in a callback. The audience doesn’t get attached to the joke because it’s within a timeframe that would make it seem like the bits could be connected. Some people may like how closely they coincide, and that’s all up to personal preference. Still, I think it insults the audience’s intelligence if you assume they won’t be able to remember something earlier in the set. I digress.
There was a good play on the release of his special through Netflix, which I think adds and detracts from the show. He prefaces the bit with a warning (another specific thing that I hate; your audience will know what you’re talking about once you start so just get on with it) that he’s going to talk about politics and gestures to a button that will be included in the Netlfix release to ‘Skip Politics’. Now, I like that it was physically interactive and brought that specific audience in on a joke, but there are a couple problems. Firstly, the bit went on way too long to be funny by the end, and I found myself wanting to hit the button to skip ten seconds ahead instead. Secondly, when Netflix eventually gives up the rights to this show, or somebody reposts the bit, the joke will become moot. Jokes with timers like this have the same effect as songs that reference the year they’re made in; sure, it will be fun for the remainder of its time, but over time it becomes something that just shows the piece’s age and doesn’t add significance.
Lastly, I think there were many opportunities for additional, more original, or even just better jokes to be included in this special. There were many times I found myself thinking that other jokes would fit into his set and flow naturally with the course of his material. Some of his punchlines were good, but many topics were overdone by either other comics or other forms of popular media. It’s great to stay relevant and talk about hot topics, but there comes the point where they become overdone. Unfortunately, Meyers’ special came out after that point.
Lobby Baby is a good example of the “classic” stand-up comic with the jokes about domestic life, politics, and getting older, and despite its lack of captivating originality, it was still an enjoyable watch. I probably wouldn’t recommend this to anyone, as I don’t quite know what to brand Meyers’ humor, and I don’t think I’ll be watching it again, but I wouldn’t advise anyone against seeing it. If you’re just looking for something to throw on in the background while you do something else, this special would be a great fit.
Watch Seth Meyers’ first stand up special on Netflix here:
